By Chris Herbst, Chartered Business Accountant in Practice (CBAP) with CIBA, General Tax Practitioner (GTP) with SAIT, Stellenbosch University. Team registered with SAIT, SAIPA and CIBA.
Many South African taxpayers run something on the side: a rental flat, a photography business, a horse that is shown at events, a crypto trading account. When that activity makes a loss, the natural expectation is that the loss reduces the tax on a salary. For most people it does. For higher earners, section 20A of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 can stop that set-off and keep the loss inside the activity that produced it. This guide explains when the rule applies, how to answer the ring-fencing question on your ITR12, and what records protect a genuine business.
What Is Section 20A Ring-Fencing?
Section 20A ring-fencing is a rule that keeps an assessed loss from a trade carried on by an individual inside that trade. A ring-fenced loss cannot be set off against your salary or other income in that year; it is carried forward and used only against future income from the same trade.
Who does section 20A apply to?
It applies to natural persons only, including individuals who trade in a partnership. SARS states in its Guide on the Ring-Fencing of Assessed Losses Arising from Certain Trades Conducted by Individuals that losses incurred by companies, close corporations and trusts are not subject to section 20A.
Is a ring-fenced loss lost?
No. Under section 20A(5) the balance of a ring-fenced loss is carried forward to the next year of assessment and set off against income from that trade when the trade becomes profitable. The loss is deferred, not disallowed.
Why does the rule exist?
SARS describes section 20A as aimed at individuals whose loss-making activity looks more like a hobby or a lifestyle choice than a business, where the loss would otherwise be funded partly by tax saved on other income. The rule is drafted as a set of objective tests, followed by an escape clause for genuine businesses.
When Does Section 20A Apply to My Losses?
Section 20A applies when two things are true in the same year: your income is at the top tax bracket level, and the trade either made losses in three of the last five years or is one of the listed "suspect" trades. If either half is missing, the loss is set off against your other income in the normal way.
What is the maximum marginal rate test?
Section 20A(2) first asks whether your taxable income, calculated before ring-fencing and with any assessed losses that were set off added back, equals or exceeds the level at which the maximum marginal rate applies. The SARS Comprehensive Guide to the ITR12 lists that level as R1 817 001 for the 2024 to 2026 years of assessment. For the 2027 tax year, the SARS rates of tax for individuals apply 45% to taxable income above R1 878 600.
Why are the losses added back?
The test measures your income before the loss reduced it. A taxpayer earning R1.9 million who sets off a R200 000 rental loss still meets the test, even though taxable income after the loss falls below the threshold. SARS works through this calculation in its examples in the ring-fencing guide.
What is the three-out-of-five-years rule?
Under section 20A(2)(a), the rule applies to any trade that is not on the listed trades list if it incurred an assessed loss in at least three of the five years ending on the last day of the current year. The current year counts. The ITR12 guide notes that a profit in one of those years delays ring-fencing, because the count is of loss years in the five-year window.
Which trades are listed as suspect trades?
Section 20A(2)(b) lists trades that face the ring-fencing test from the first loss year, without waiting for three losses. The table below summarises them.
- Sport by you or a relative: Exception in the Act: None; Section: 20A(2)(b)(i)
- Dealing in collectibles: Exception in the Act: None; Section: 20A(2)(b)(ii)
- Rental of residential accommodation: Exception in the Act: 80% let to non-relatives for half the year; Section: 20A(2)(b)(iii)
- Rental of vehicles, aircraft or boats: Exception in the Act: 80% used by non-relatives for half the year; Section: 20A(2)(b)(iv)
- Animal showing: Exception in the Act: None; Section: 20A(2)(b)(v)
- Farming or animal breeding: Exception in the Act: Carried on full-time; Section: 20A(2)(b)(vi)
- Performing or creative arts: Exception in the Act: None; Section: 20A(2)(b)(vii)
- Gambling or betting: Exception in the Act: None; Section: 20A(2)(b)(viii)
- Acquisition or disposal of crypto assets: Exception in the Act: None; Section: 20A(2)(b)(ix)
A relative, as the ITR12 guide defines it, is your spouse, parent, child, stepchild, brother, sister, grandchild or grandparent. A rental property or a vehicle that meets the 80% exception is not a listed trade, but it still falls under the three-out-of-five-years rule.
How Does the Facts and Circumstances Escape Clause Work?
Section 20A(3) switches ring-fencing off where the trade is a business with a reasonable prospect of deriving taxable income, other than taxable capital gains, within a reasonable period. The test is objective: SARS weighs the factors the Act lists, not your intention alone.
Which factors does SARS look at?
The Act directs special regard to these factors:
- the gross income of the trade in the year compared with its allowable deductions;
- the level of activity, and spending on advertising, promoting or selling;
- whether the trade is run in a commercial manner: full-time employees, the commercial setting of the premises, equipment used only for the trade, and the time you spend at the premises;
- the number of loss years compared with the years since the trade started, taking into account unexpected events and the nature of the business;
- your business plans, and the changes you make to reach taxable income;
- how far the trade's assets are used, or available, for your or a relative's recreation or personal consumption.
What counts as a reasonable period?
The Act does not set a number of years. SARS explains in the ring-fencing guide that the period depends on the nature of the business, so a start-up farm and a consulting practice are measured differently. Your business plan and your results against it are the evidence.
Does the escape clause always remain open?
No. Section 20A(4) closes it for a listed trade, other than farming, that has incurred assessed losses in at least six of the ten years ending on the last day of the current year. From that point the loss is ring-fenced whatever the facts show. Farming keeps access to the escape clause.
Does Section 20A Apply to Crypto Trading Losses?
Yes, where the crypto activity is a trade. SARS confirms in its Draft Guide to the Taxation of Crypto Assets (published for comment in July 2026) that the trades listed in section 20A(2)(b) include the acquisition or disposal of any crypto asset, so a trading loss faces the ring-fencing test from the first loss year if the income threshold is met.
Does it apply to crypto held as an investment?
Section 20A deals with assessed losses from a trade. Crypto held on capital account produces capital gains and capital losses under the Eighth Schedule, which follow their own rules. Whether your crypto activity is a trade or an investment is decided on your own facts: your intention when you bought, how long you held, how often you traded, how the activity was organised and the other facts SARS weighs. Our guide on crypto losses on your tax return covers the reporting side.
I live outside South Africa. Does this apply to me?
This guide is written for South African tax residents. If you hold crypto and are tax resident elsewhere, CountDeFi (https://www.countdefi.com) serves crypto taxpayers outside South Africa.
How Does a Ring-Fenced Loss Get Used Later?
A ring-fenced loss is set off against income from the same trade in later years. Section 20A(6) widens what counts as income from that trade, so the loss is not stranded when the trade stops.
What counts as income from the trade?
Income from the trade includes recoupments under section 8 of amounts deducted in carrying on the trade, and amounts derived from disposing of the trade's assets after the trade has ceased.
Can a ring-fenced loss reduce a capital gain?
Yes, in one case. The ITR12 guide explains that section 20A(6)(b) allows a ring-fenced loss to be set off against the taxable capital gain on an asset used in the trade, once the trade has ceased and the asset is sold. No set-off is permitted for an asset sold while the trade is still running. The taxable capital gain is then declared in the Local Business, Trade and Professional Income section under the same identifier, description and source code as the trade, and not in the Capital Gains section, so that it is not taxed twice.
How are several farms or rentals counted?
Section 20A(7) deems all farming activities of a person to be a single trade. For lettings, the ITR12 guide notes that more than one property can be a single trade in some circumstances, declared as one entry with combined financial statements.
How Do I Declare a Ring-Fenced Loss on My ITR12?
You answer a Y or N ring-fencing question for each loss-making trade on the ITR12, and keep the records that support your answer. The steps below follow the eFiling return.
Step 1: Activate the right sections in the return wizard
On eFiling, open the ITR12 and, in the form wizard, select the local business, trade and professional income section and, for property, the rental income section. Each trade is a separate activity with its own source code. The return allows up to eight activities. See declaring side income to SARS for the business section in more detail.
Step 2: Complete the income, expenditure and adjustments
Enter the trade's income, its expenses and the add-back and allowable adjustments. For rental, the return calculates Taxable Profit (code 4210) or Taxable Loss (code 4211). For property advice, see our guide to rental income tax in South Africa.
Step 3: Answer the ring-fencing question
When the activity shows a loss, the return makes the question "Should the loss incurred be excluded (ring-fenced) for the calculation of your tax liability?" mandatory. The ITR12 guide states that Y removes the loss from your taxable income for the year, and N claims it against other income.
Step 4: If you answer N, keep the escape-clause evidence
The ITR12 guide states that a taxpayer who answers N must retain documentation based on the facts and circumstances factors: financial statements, the business plan, marketing spend, staff and premises records. These are what you upload if SARS opens a verification.
Step 5: Carry the balance forward under the same activity
Use the same description, source code and identifier for the trade each year, so the ring-fenced balance follows the activity. Section 20A(8) requires you to state the nature of the business on your return when the ring-fencing conditions apply.
Does ring-fencing affect my provisional tax?
Yes. If you are a provisional taxpayer, your IRP6 estimate should use taxable income after ring-fencing, because a ring-fenced loss does not reduce the year's tax. Our guide on IRP6 and ITR12 explains how the two returns connect.
What Are the Common Mistakes With Section 20A?
Most section 20A problems come from answering the ring-fencing question without checking the tests, or from claiming a loss without the records to back it.
Testing income after the loss
The threshold test adds back the losses that were set off. Testing taxable income after the loss understates income and lets a ring-fenced loss through.
Forgetting the relatives rule on rentals
A flat let to your child, or a holiday home used mostly by family, does not meet the 80% non-relative exception and is a listed trade.
Answering N with no business plan
The escape clause is judged on evidence. A loss claimed against salary with no plan, no marketing and assets used privately is the pattern SARS looks for.
Changing the activity description each year
A new description or source code breaks the link to the carried-forward balance, and the loss does not follow the trade.
Declaring the post-cessation gain twice
The ITR12 guide warns that a taxable capital gain used against a ring-fenced loss must not also appear in the Capital Gains section.
Ignoring losses from before March 2004
Section 20A(9) excludes assessed losses from years ending on or before 29 February 2004 from the loss-year counts. They do not count toward three-of-five or six-of-ten.
How Does Section 20A Interact With Other Rules?
Section 20A works after the ordinary deduction rules. An expense must first be deductible under the general rules before section 20A decides whether the resulting loss is set off against other income.
Is section 20A the same as the section 20 assessed loss rule?
No. Section 20 is the general rule that sets off an assessed loss against income and carries a balance forward. Section 20A overrides it for individuals in the circumstances above. For sole proprietors, our tax tips for sole proprietors cover the deductions that come first.
Does married in community of property change anything?
For rental income, the ITR12 guide states that a spouse married in community of property declares the full profit or loss and SARS applies the 50% split. The ring-fencing question is still answered on the return.
Do You Need Help With Section 20A?
If a side business, rental or crypto trading account made a loss and your income is near the top bracket, the ring-fencing answer on your ITR12 changes the tax you pay. We prepare returns with the section 20A tests worked through and the evidence file ready for SARS. Contact us to book a call, see our personal tax plans, or read more on crypto tax for South African residents and the personal tax guides.

