Tax guides

IRP3(c) Directive: Fixed Amount of Tax Explained

An IRP3(c) is the SARS application for a directive that your employer deducts a fixed rand amount of employees' tax each month. It is used for financial hardship under paragraph 11 of the Fourth Schedule, an assessed loss carried forward, and trusts that own a living annuity. You or your tax practitioner apply on eFiling.

CH Consulting blog header reading Personal Tax Insights

By Chris Herbst, Chartered Business Accountant in Practice (CBAP) with CIBA, General Tax Practitioner (GTP) with SAIT, Stellenbosch University. Team registered with SAIT, SAIPA and CIBA.

Most salaried South Africans never need to think about how their employer calculates PAYE. The monthly tax tables do the work, and the ITR12 squares the year. The IRP3(c) exists for the people the tables do not fit: someone whose circumstances have changed so much that the normal deduction causes real hardship, someone carrying an assessed loss into the new year, and the trust owner of a living annuity. This guide explains what the directive is, who qualifies, how the fixed amount is calculated on the form, how to apply on eFiling and how the result reaches your IRP5 and your ITR12. It sits next to our guides on the IRP3(b) fixed percentage directive and the IRP3 lump sum directives.

What is an IRP3(c) directive?

An IRP3(c) is the SARS application for a directive that tells your employer to deduct employees' tax at a fixed rand amount each month instead of under the tax tables. The SARS Guide for Employers in respect of Employees' Tax lists it as "Employees' Tax to be deducted at a fixed amount", with hardship under paragraph 11 of the Fourth Schedule and an assessed loss carried forward as its examples.

What does the "c" stand for?

The letter only identifies the form in the IRP3 family. The IRP3(a) covers severance benefits paid by an employer, the IRP3(b) a fixed percentage, the IRP3(c) a fixed amount and the IRP3(s) amounts included under section 8A or 8C, according to the employer guide's list of directive forms.

What is the full name of the form?

The current form is titled "Application for a Tax Directive: Fixed amount for Individuals and Trust Owners of a Living Annuity". The title tells you its two audiences: individual employees and the trusts that own living annuity policies.

Is the IRP3(c) the same as a hardship directive?

A hardship directive is one of the reasons for an IRP3(c), not a separate form. The SARS tax directive page states that the taxpayer or their tax practitioner completes the IRP3(b) or the IRP3(c) to ask SARS to alleviate hardship, and that each case is reviewed on an individual basis.

Who qualifies for an IRP3(c) fixed amount directive?

The IRP3(c) form asks you to mark one of three reasons: an assessed loss carried forward from the previous year of assessment, paragraph 11 of the Fourth Schedule, or trust owner of a living annuity. If none of the three describes you, the monthly tax tables already apply to you correctly and there is nothing to apply for.

What counts as hardship under paragraph 11?

Paragraph 11 of the Fourth Schedule to the Income Tax Act lets the Commissioner, having regard to the circumstances of the case, authorise an employer to deduct no employees' tax, a specified amount, or an amount at a specified rate or scale. The employer guide states that the directive is issued to alleviate hardship due to circumstances outside the employee's control and to correct an error in the calculation of employees' tax.

What must I show SARS for a hardship application?

The SARS page "I want to get a tax directive" states that the taxpayer must assure SARS that the situation is outside their control and has caused financial hardship. Your application should therefore explain the event, show its effect on your finances and attach the documents that prove both.

How does an assessed loss carried forward qualify?

If your last assessment closed with an assessed loss, for example from a trade you carry on next to your employment, that loss is set off against the new year's income. The IRP3(c) calculation subtracts the "assessed loss brought forward" from gross income, so the fixed amount reflects the lower taxable income you expect for the year.

Why does a living annuity trust use the IRP3(c)?

The form has a "Details of Insurer" section where you mark a living annuity or a guaranteed annuity and give the policy number and insurer. It lets the trust that owns a living annuity apply for a fixed amount of tax on the annuity it receives, with the trust's PAYE reference and trust deed number on the form.

Who does not need an IRP3(c)?

An employee with one employer, no assessed loss and no change in circumstances is taxed correctly under the monthly tables. A large medical bill or a retirement annuity contribution on its own is claimed on the ITR12, where SARS allows it on assessment, so it is not a reason to apply for a fixed amount during the year.

How is the fixed amount on an IRP3(c) calculated?

You calculate it yourself on the form, and SARS reviews it. The IRP3(c) states that a calculation is required showing how the fixed amount was arrived at, based where relevant on your latest year of assessment and adjusted for any expected increase in income.

What lines does the calculation have?

The form's calculation block runs in this order:

  1. Gross income for the year applied for.
  2. Less the assessed loss brought forward.
  3. Less other losses, each specified.
  4. Less admissible expenditure.
  5. Equals estimated taxable income.
  6. Tax payable on that income, divided by 12.
  7. Equals the fixed amount of tax payable per month.

Which year's figures should I use?

Use your latest assessment as the base, then adjust it for what you know about the year ahead, such as an increase in salary. The form asks for this adjustment in so many words, so a calculation built only on last year's figures, with a known raise left out, is incomplete.

Can I run a simulation of the IRP3(c) first?

No. The SARS Guide to the Tax Directive Functionality on eFiling states that the simulation option is available on all application forms except the IRP3(b), IRP3(c), IRP3(f) and IRP3(q). Your own calculation on the form is the estimate you work from.

How does the IRP3(c) compare with the other IRP3 forms?

Each IRP3 form sets a different basis for employees' tax, and the right one depends on why the tax tables do not fit you. The table summarises the forms an individual meets most often, using the employer guide's descriptions.

  • IRP3(c): Who applies: You or your tax practitioner; What it sets: A fixed amount per month
  • IRP3(b): Who applies: You or your tax practitioner; What it sets: A fixed percentage
  • IRP3(a): Who applies: Your employer; What it sets: Tax on a severance benefit
  • IRP3(s): Who applies: Your employer; What it sets: Tax on section 8A or 8C gains

When should I use the IRP3(b) instead?

Use the IRP3(b) when your income is commission or you are a personal service provider, because it sets a percentage that moves with what you earn. Our IRP3(b) guide covers that form, including the automated percentage SARS now calculates.

How do I apply for an IRP3(c) on eFiling?

You apply on eFiling only. The SARS tax directive page states that IRP3(b) and IRP3(c) hard copy applications are no longer submitted through email, and the eFiling guide states that on the Individual portfolio you can apply only for the IRP3(b) and IRP3(c) for yourself.

Step 1: Activate Tax Directives on your profile

On eFiling, open your portfolio's tax type management and activate Tax Directives. The eFiling guide explains that the Tax Directives menu appears once the tax type is activated.

Step 2: Open the Request screen

Select Tax Directives on the top menu, then Request, and choose the IRP3(c). If a practitioner applies for you, they do this from the Tax Practitioner portfolio, which the eFiling guide states offers the IRP3(b), IRP3(c), IRP3(q) and IRP3(f) for clients.

Step 3: Complete taxpayer, employer and representative details

Enter your details, your employer's PAYE reference number and contact person, and, for a living annuity trust, the insurer and policy number. A practitioner completes the representative section with their PR number.

Step 4: Complete the calculation and the reason

Fill in each line of the calculation, mark the reason for the application and state the fixed amount you are applying for. The form also asks whether a fixed percentage directive was issued to you for the same employer in the previous year.

Step 5: Upload the supporting documents and submit

The form's notes for individuals require copies of your letter of employment, service contracts and other documents that verify your terms of employment. Add the documents that prove the hardship or the assessed loss, then submit. Keep the same papers ready, because SARS can ask for them again in a verification of your return.

Step 6: Give the issued directive to your payroll

Once SARS issues the directive, download it from eFiling and hand it to your employer. The employer guide states that employers may decline photocopies and may under no circumstances deviate from the directive's instructions.

How long is an IRP3(c) directive valid?

An IRP3(c) runs for the tax year it was issued for and never longer than twelve months. The IRP3(c) form states that a fixed amount directive cannot be applied retrospectively, is valid until the end of the year in which it was issued, and needs a new application each year if you still need it.

Does the directive move with me to a new job?

No. The form's notes state that directives are not transferable and that a new application is made after a change in employment position. If you have more than one employer, you apply separately for each one.

When does a directive for a trust expire?

For trusts and companies, the form states that the directive expires if the concession is abused or circumstances change, and also when a further directive is issued. The trust's PAYE reconciliations must be up to date for the directive to stay valid.

How does an IRP3(c) affect my IRP5 and ITR12?

The directive changes how much PAYE is withheld during the year, not how much tax you owe for the year. Your final liability is set when SARS assesses your ITR12, and the SARS tax directive page states that some taxpayers still have an amount to pay, or a refund due, once the final liability is determined on assessment.

Where does the PAYE under the directive show?

The tax your employer withheld under the directive appears on your IRP5 as employees' tax, the same way it would under the tables. Our guide on how to read your IRP5 for your ITR12 shows where each figure lands on the return.

Do I become a provisional taxpayer?

The directive itself does not change your status. If you earn income other than remuneration, such as the trade that produced your assessed loss, the SARS provisional tax page states that there is no registration process: the onus is on you to determine whether you are liable for provisional tax and to request and submit the IRP6 on eFiling. Our guide to filing provisional tax in South Africa walks through it.

What are the common mistakes with an IRP3(c)?

Most refused or troublesome applications fail on the calculation or the evidence, not on the form. These are the mistakes we see most often:

  • Choosing the wrong form. Commission income belongs on the IRP3(b). The IRP3(c) is for hardship, an assessed loss or a living annuity trust.
  • Leaving out an expected increase. The form asks you to adjust your latest assessment for any increase in income. A calculation that ignores a known raise sets the fixed amount too low and leaves tax to pay on assessment.
  • Applying once for two employers. Each employer needs its own application, according to the form's notes.
  • Expecting a refund of past months. The directive cannot be applied retrospectively, so it does not change PAYE already deducted.
  • Forgetting to renew. The directive ends with the tax year. Payroll returns to the tax tables unless a new directive is issued.
  • Thin evidence of hardship. SARS reviews each case individually and expects you to show that the situation is outside your control.

Do You Need Help With an IRP3(c) Directive?

We prepare IRP3(c) applications through the Tax Practitioner portfolio, build the calculation from your latest assessment and assemble the supporting documents, then carry the result through to your ITR12 on our personal tax plans. If you also run a trade next to your employment, our provisional tax service covers the IRP6 returns. More guides are on our personal tax hub. Contact us to talk through your situation.

Frequently asked questions

What is an IRP3(c) tax directive?

It is a SARS directive telling your employer to deduct a fixed rand amount of PAYE each month instead of using the tax tables. It is used for hardship, an assessed loss carried forward and trusts that own a living annuity.

Who can apply for an IRP3(c)?

You can apply for yourself on the Individual eFiling portfolio, or your tax practitioner can apply for you from their Tax Practitioner portfolio. A trust that owns a living annuity also applies on the form.

Can I submit an IRP3(c) by email?

No. SARS states that IRP3(b) and IRP3(c) hard copy applications are no longer submitted through email. You apply on eFiling.

What is the difference between an IRP3(c) and an IRP3(b)?

The IRP3(c) sets a fixed amount of employees' tax. The IRP3(b) sets a fixed percentage and is used by commission earners and personal service providers.

What is paragraph 11 of the Fourth Schedule?

It lets the Commissioner authorise your employer to deduct no PAYE, a specified amount, or PAYE at a specified rate, having regard to your circumstances. It is the legal basis of a hardship directive.

What counts as financial hardship for SARS?

SARS expects you to show that the situation is outside your control and has caused financial hardship. Each application is reviewed on its own facts.

Can I get an IRP3(c) because of an assessed loss?

Yes. The form lists an assessed loss carried forward from the previous year of assessment as a reason, and the calculation deducts the loss brought forward from gross income.

How do I calculate the fixed amount on an IRP3(c)?

Start with gross income for the year, deduct the assessed loss brought forward, other losses and admissible expenditure, calculate the tax on the result and divide it by 12. That gives the fixed amount per month.

Can I simulate an IRP3(c) on eFiling?

No. The SARS eFiling guide states that simulation is not available for the IRP3(b), IRP3(c), IRP3(f) and IRP3(q). Your own calculation on the form is your estimate.

What documents do I need for an IRP3(c)?

The form asks for your letter of employment, service contracts and other documents verifying your terms of employment. Add the evidence for the hardship or the assessed loss you rely on.

How long is an IRP3(c) valid?

It runs until the end of the tax year in which it was issued and never longer than twelve months. You apply again each year if you still need it.

Can an IRP3(c) be backdated?

No. The form states that a fixed amount directive cannot be applied retrospectively, so PAYE already deducted is not changed by it.

I have two employers. Do I need two IRP3(c) applications?

Yes. The form states that a separate application is made for each employer.

Does my IRP3(c) carry over when I change jobs?

No. Directives are not transferable, and you apply again after a change in employment position.

Can my employer ignore the directive?

No. The SARS employer guide states that employers may under no circumstances deviate from the instructions on a directive.

Will I still have to file an ITR12 if I have an IRP3(c)?

Yes, if you are required to file. The directive only changes the PAYE withheld during the year, and your final tax is set on the ITR12 assessment.

Can I end up owing SARS after an IRP3(c)?

Yes. SARS states that some taxpayers still have an amount to pay, or a refund due, once the final liability is determined on assessment.

Where does the IRP3(c) PAYE appear on my IRP5?

It appears as employees' tax on your IRP5, as PAYE under the tax tables would. The ITR12 assessment credits it against your tax for the year.

Can a living annuity be taxed under an IRP3(c)?

Yes, where a trust owns the living annuity. The form has a section for the insurer, the policy number and whether it is a living or guaranteed annuity.

Does an IRP3(c) make me a provisional taxpayer?

No. Your provisional tax status depends on whether you earn income other than remuneration, as SARS sets out on its provisional tax page.

Sources

Chris Herbst

Chris Herbst

Founder of CH Consulting. Chartered Business Accountant in Practice (CBAP, CIBA) and General Tax Practitioner (GTP, SAIT), working in South African tax since 2009.